• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

AJ's Pizza Blanchester: Authentic Homemade Pizza & Local Flavor in Blanchester, OH

AJ’s Pizza Blanchester, nestled at 653 W Main St, offers a cozy, family-run dining experience defined by fresh, homemade dough and sauce. Known for its diverse crust options—thin, traditional, and thick—AJ’s delights with creative menu items like their standout taco pizza and savory pig tail garlic bread with cheese and bacon. The flavors strike a homey balance, though some crave bolder seasoning. Alongside classic pizzas, they serve hearty subs, family-sized salads, and unique bites like meatball shooters. This local gem’s warm atmosphere pairs perfectly with its quality ingredients, making it a must-visit for anyone seeking authentic, comforting pizza in Blanchester.

AJ's Pizza Blanchester at a glance

  • Address 653 W Main St, Blanchester, OH 45107, United States
  • Phone +1 937-783-0777
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant , Cheesesteak restaurant .
  • Popular for Lunch , Dinner .

Photos & Gallery

AJ's Pizza Blanchester: Reviews & Ratings

Ben Patrick
4

Tried AJs for the first time last night. Offering only carry out or delivery, it's located in Blanchester and is very popular among the local folks. 3 different crust selections from thin, traditional and thick it seemed to really just be about the 'bone' versus the entire crust. I do wish the crust bone was seasoned. Overall it was pretty good very very light amount of sauce. Is looking for that seasoning, and my bacon overwhelmed my pizza, I think it might have been like maple bacon. We had the all meat, cheese, and an order of pig tails..a spin on bread sticks with bacon.

Crystal “CakMax86” K
5

You don’t know how excited I am to have a local pizza place less than 15 minutes from my house that reminds me of home!!!!!!! Their taco pizza is out of this world. I can’t be more happy!!!!!! if you’re real nice, she might get the taste test a cupcake

Madison Rubel
5

Great pizza, super nice and helpful workers. Will definitely be back.

Gary Branam
4

Not just another pizza place. This Mom-n-Pop gem, serves up home made pizza dough and sauce. With a menu that includes family sized salads, pig tail twisted garlic bread with cheese and bacon, pizzas of course and sandwiches along with hogies and their amazing Meatball Shooters. If the food wasn't enough reason to stay, the down home family atmosphere will keep you coming back for more. Give AJ's a try, you won't regret it.

Melissa Spaulding
5

It was our first time trying AJs since moving to Blanchester. We were very happy with the pizza and Italian sub. Ingredients are fresh, and the food had the perfect finished crisp to the crust and sub.

Mike Prell
5

It's been a while since I've been able to find a Fresh pizza dough shop. Brings back good memories of Capri pizza growing up in Cincinnati. AJ's is much better though, the thin crust crispy bubbles makes it a one of a kind crunchy bite!

Chuck Fleming
5

I love this place. Wings and pizza are excellent. Can’t go wrong here

Jessica
5

The best Cauliflower pizza around! The chicken Bacon Ranch is fantastic!

Location

  • AJ's Pizza Blanchester
    AJ's Pizza Blanchester
    653 W Main St, Blanchester, OH 45107, United States Hotline: +1 937-783-0777

AJ's Pizza Blanchester stands out as a true local treasure nestled in the heart of Blanchester, Ohio. This mom-and-pop pizzeria offers a warm, welcoming atmosphere paired with a menu that feels like a loving nod to traditional, homemade flavors. Their commitment to fresh ingredients shines through every dish, from their signature pizzas crafted with homemade dough and sauce to their inventive sides like pig tail twisted garlic bread loaded with cheese and bacon.

The variety in crust options—thin, traditional, and thick—caters to all pizza lovers, though the crust’s subtle seasoning leaves room for a more pronounced kick. What truly captivates is their range of specialty pizzas; in particular, the all-meat and taco pizzas offer bold, satisfying experiences that reflect AJ’s creative spirit. The taco pizza, praised by locals, brings a unique twist that’s both memorable and crave-worthy.

Beyond the pizzas, the menu’s diversity is impressive, featuring family-sized salads, hearty sandwiches, and intriguing items like Meatball Shooters. Each plate carries a comforting, homemade feel that evokes the warmth of family gatherings. Service here is friendly and attentive, heightening the overall experience and making every visit feel personal.

In sum, AJ's Pizza Blanchester isn’t just a place to grab a quick slice—it’s a community hub where genuine flavors and heartfelt hospitality converge. Whether you’re indulging in their bacon-laden pig tails or savoring the crisp Italian sub, this spot delivers quality and a sense of belonging. For anyone seeking a pizzeria with character and a homemade touch, AJ’s promises a satisfying and sincere meal every time.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Kerbside pickup
    • No-contact delivery
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards